4 Comments

Minor irritation - bar graphs starting at non-zero… straight out of “how to lie with statistics”. Otherwise quite an interesting POV.

Expand full comment
author

Not really, if you are looking at variations around e.g. Labour votes around 10 million, then starting y-axis at zero would make the chart pretty well useless, starting at the lowest point in the time series is the approach that makes sense.

Expand full comment

I respectfully disagree. A bar chart implicitly shows values proportionate to the bar’s length. If you want to do what you did to show the variation better I believe the recommended way is to include a zigzag break across the bottom section of the bars to show you’ve truncated them. Stephen Few. Edward Tufte have written books on good data presentation. Contentious to some :-)

Expand full comment
author

OK understood.

Expand full comment